Texas Judiciary Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words

Texas Judiciary - Assignment ExampleThe police investigator, Roberts, went beyond the normal limit when interrogating a instruction execution suspect, Mr. Wilson. The police detective used falsified records to show that the appellant had been involved in the murder through a fingerprints report. According to the detective, the prints were open on the magazine of the murder weapon. In this way, the detective lured the appellant into the confession that he indeed shot the victim. The trial judge refused to drop the evidence and denied the appellant request to recant the confession. The appellant court found pop that the detective was in violation of the Texas Penal Code section 37.09 that inhibit the officers from using fabricated reports to get confessions from suspects. In addition, the court found out that the trial judge erred in admitting the evidence since it was inadmissible under clause 38.23 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Despite the decision, several judges dissented on the opinion that detectives be faced with a hard task of balancing the societal concerns and the rights granted by the Constitution The fact that the appellant confessed the murder is enough to convict him differently the state would risk setting the guilty free due to the interrogation methods. If I were a judge, I would concur with the dissenters since the fact that the appellant confessed to a murder could be a starting point to get the reliability of the evidence. Fingerprints are unique and thus the appellant could not have confessed if he was pretty positive(predicate) that he had not used the murder weapon.